Introduction
Talking about the gender here is part of thing that never finished in our ear, because of that I want to try to explain about it using discourse analysis. The study of discourse and gender is an interdisciplinary endeavor undertaken by scholars in linguistic, anthropology, communication, social psychology, education literature and other disciplines. At its heart is focus on, first, the linguistic resources individuals draw on to present themselves as gendered being in relation to other aspects of the self within the constraints of their communities, more or less conforming to or resisting these constraints; and, second, the discursive construction of gender and its many components trough words and images. Given the complexity of gender as a social phenomenon, the study of gender and discourse requires attention to culture influences the favor gendered ways of speaking and negotiating both connection and power, the fluidity of gender as performance and the societal constraints on gender performance; and the multiple interrelations among gender, discourse, and social meaning.
Gender and discourse interface in many more epistemological sites than can be represented in one collection .especially in missing word SEX in Madura example. In Madura there are many society that has been misunderstand about the word Sex actually, the society always suppose to the word focusing to bad attitude or bad culture that had.
In what follows we first discuss the early work that inaugurated and established the field of gender and language research. So we describe research that focuses on the talk or text of women and men, including developments in theorizing the relationship between gender and discourse. The next section presents resent themes and trends, including research on the intersectionality of race, class, sexuality and other facets of identity in the study of gender and discourse; discursive differences within, as well as between, groups; and how normative identities and practices are supported or opposed.
So because of hat when we face the reality, many people or society did not know how to the differences between gender and sex. In this chapter we want to try explain the gender using discourse analysis. In discourse analysis we focus on the object is on the society in Madura especially. In Madura society, from Bangkalan until Sumenep regency, many different culture and different speaking and missing knowledge. Part of the regency we take example of Madura that missing knowledge about the gender and sex. When the society hearing the sex word from other people, certain the society suppose that the people have bad attitude, because the people suppose the sex word prohibited thing in their religion.
2.1 Research question
a. What are the relations word SEX in the discourse and gender?
b. Why the data chosen to analyze using discourse and gender?
3.1 objectives
Based on the statement of problems above, this study is intended:
a. to know the relation word SEX in discourse and gender analyze
b. to know the reason why the data chosen to analyze using the discourse and gender analysis.
4.1 scope and limitation
The scope of this study is discourse and grammar. In order to help the study achieve the objectives of the study. Not only that but also know what hidden meaning in the word SEX actually. the limit of the study is about the reaction of the society Madura.
Chapter II
This chapter consists of the research design, data and sources of data, and technique of collecting data.
1.2 Research Design
The year 1975 was key in launching the field of language and gender. That year saw the publication of three book that proved pivotal; Robin Lakoff’s language and woman’s place ( the first part if which had appeared in language and society tow years earlier (1973a). These pioneering work emerged during the second wave feminist movement of the 1970s,1as scholars began to question both the identification of male norms as human norms, and the biological determination of women’s and men’s behavior.( the rejection of the letter is reflected in the term typically used the characterize and castigate it, “essentialism .”) A conceptual split was posited between biological “SEX” sociocultural construct of “gender,” although “gender” is now used conventionally for both. Early language and gender research focused on documenting empirical differences between women’s and men’s speech especially in cross sex interaction; describing women’s speech in practicular; and, for many, identifying the role of language in creating and maintaining social inequality between women and men.
The goal of uncovering the role of language in maintaining gender inequality is evident in the field’s foundational text, Robin Lakoff’s Language and women’s place, one of the first to call attention to gender differences in ways of speaking Lakoff describes her book as an attempt to provide diagnostic evidence from language use for one type of Inequity that has been claimed to exist in our society: that between the roles of men and women in (1975:4), She posits a cycle that begin with the unequal role of women and men in society, resulting in differential gender socialization by which girls learn to use “ nonforceful style.” Thus conforming to social norms of womanhood.
The use women language in turn denies moment access to power, thus rainforcing social inequality. Lakoff identified linguistic forms by which women’s languageweakens or mitigates the force of an utterance, weaker expletives ( oh” dear” versus “damn”).trivializing adjectives (dinine versus great) tag question used when expressing speakers opinion ( the way prices are rising is horrendous isn’t ?)rising intonation in declaratives as seen in the second part of the sequence what is for dinner? “ Roast beef?”
Lakoff’s work launched the exploration of gender and discourse. In keeping with the introspective method typical of her field, theoretical linguistic, Lakoff based her insights on her own observation and intuition. Subsequent studies applied her framework to a range of data and either confirmed her observation or found exception in particular contecxts. Leaper and Robnett performed a meta analysis of 29 studies the examained, among the others linguistic features, “ four forms of tentative language” as describes by Lakoff: expression of uncertainly including disclaimers “ I am not sure if this is right, but ….” And qualifiers ( somewhat) hedges, including prefatory remarks ( I guess) and modifiers ( Kinds of); tag question and the intensifiers very, so and really (130).
1.3 Data and source of data
The source data is a talking word SEX by Sumenep Madura. The data of this study is about the intraction of the social life when the society Sumenep Madura talking abaout sex analysis by discourse and gender that consist to bad crhacter.
1.4 technique of collecting data
The technique to collect the data are reading and highlighting the source of data. Reading is conducted to found the data that the researcher needed. Highlighting is to spread on the evidence of the analysis such as the researches give a color the data which are found on the text that are talked by society of Sumenep Madura.
Chapter III
FINDING AND DISCUSSION
The publication of Deborah Tannen’s you just don’t understand in 1990 can be seen ushering in the text phase of discourse and gender research, based on attention the book received both within and outside the field. During the 1990s and beyond, it served as Lakoff’s language and women’s place had before as the point of departure for numerous studies, both of touchtone for developing further research and as bĂȘte noir against which to define argements, As with Lakoff, it continuous to inspire and be applied in currence research. Written for general rather than an academic audience, this book combined a range of scholarly essays work with everyday conversional examples to support and expand Maltz and Bolker’s 1982 claim that conversation between woment and men could be understood, metaphorically, as cross cultural communication. Both befor and after 1990, Tannan published scholarly essays on the topic, u number of which are collected in her 1986 book gender and discourse, however, it is you just don’t understand that is most often cited and responded to.
Combining Gumper’s cross cultural perspective which later came to be known as interactional sociolinguistic, Lakoff framework of gender related communicative syle and politemess, and her own prior work on conversational style, Tanen posited that gender related patterns of discourse from a coherent web motivated by women ‘s an men’s approach to social relationship. She concluded that linguistic strategies that have been found to characterize women’s and men’s speech could be understood as serving interaction goal.: Where as the speakers continually negotiate relative connection how close or distant are they, or do want to be as well as status ( Who’s up, who’s down), conversationally rituals learned by girl and maintained by women tend to focus on the connection dimension. while ritual learned by boys and maintained by on girl and boy socialization, Tenen noted that girls and women are often sensitive to being left out or pushed away, where as boy and men are often sensitive to being put down or pushed around. Conversational rituals associated with each gender, then tend to serve those sensitivities.
Communicative strategies associated with women, accordingly, are based on symmetry. For example, Tanen 1990 describes a conversational ritual common among women, displaying similarities and matching experiences “77, which my take form troble talk supporting the finding, Coates 1996,2013a:43 notes that reciprocal self dis closure trough repetition of syntactic pattern and key words and phrase, and also frequently involves matching troubels. Tanen notes that bonding trough talk about trouble is a common activity for women trough out the world. The contrast is not that boy and men don’t seek bonding but rather that they often accomplish it in different way. For example, Tanen 1990, 1994, 1996b, 1998 shows that many conversational ritual common among men are based on ritual opposition or "agomsm." Thus boys and men may show affection by teasing or playfully insulting each other, and may explore ideas by "playing devil's advocate," that is, by offering challenges, counter-challenges, and vigorous debate. Just as troubles talk appears among women cross-culturally, men in disparate parts of the world engage ina "war of words," in which they "vie with one another to devise clever insults, topping each other both in the intensity of the insult and the skill of the insulter" (Tannen 1998:194). Tannen stresses that it is the use of ritualized opposition, or agcnlsm. that is associated with boys and men; thus, little boys frequently play-fight as a favored game.
Though little girls rarely fight for fun, girls and women certainly fight in the literal
sense; they fight when they mean it (197).
During the 19905,many scholars routinely classified research into two categories: a"power" or "dominance" approach which focused on social inequality as the source
of gendered patterns of language use and a "cultural" or "difference" approach which
focused on sex-separate socialization as the source of differences. This characterization
of research, initially proposed by Henley and Kramarae (1991), was, to a great extent,
disciplinary: the research they labeled as "dominance," including their own, stemmed
from the fields of communication and sociology, whereas the research they labeled
as "difference," predominantly that of Maltz and Barker (1982) and Tannen (1990),
stemmed from anthropology (in the case of Maltz and Barker) or linguistics (in the
case of Tannen). The distinction was used primarily to fault the "difference" approach
for, purportedly, not incorporating into analysis, or even denying, the societal subjugation
of women. Eckert and Connell- Ginet (2013: 50) argue for a balanced approach,
because "[ejach of these emphases points to important aspects of gender practice" so
that "no single approach can tell the entire story, and a focus on one approach will miss
important things, and thus distort the overall picture. A focus on difference tends
to dislodge dominance and structures of male privilege. A focus on difference .. tends
to dislodge dominance and structures of male privilege. A focus on dominance, on the
other hand, tends to downplay the importance of difference in experience and beliefs."
Tannen and other linguists have argued that the difference-dominance distinction is fundamentally spurious, because the two dynamics are inextricably intertwined. They point of moreover, that research relegated to the "difference" camp grows out of Int~rachon.al Sociolinguistics, a theoretical framework founded on the assumption that social such as dominance and subordination are in part constructed and reinforced. interaction. Indeed, a concern with social inequality and injustice motivates and drives Gumperz's (1982) foundational work. As early studies by Brown (1980) and good (1980? demonstrate, the meanings or functions of linguistic features depend their immediate context of use. Interpretations about dominance and solidarity relation are context-specific as well.
In clarifying and complexifying the ways that gender patterns dovetail with the universal human goals of balancing the simultaneous yet often conflicti.ng needs to negotiate both status (including dominance and connection, Tannen (1996b) posits a grid in which horizontal axis runs between the poles of connection and distance while a vertical axis runs between the poles of hierarchy and equality. She suggests that all utterances fall somewhere on the grid. Furtherrnore, she stresses, individual utterances are often ambiguous: they may create either connection or hierarchy. They also are often polysemy: they may. ere. ate both at once. Tannen (1989, 1993) uses interruption as a paradigm case of ambiguity and polysemy. Beginning to speak when another holds the floor may seem to be (and has been taken by researchers to be) a self -evident display of conversational dominance, usurping another's speaking rights. However, there are many for whom talking-along is not an interruption but rather what Tannen calls" cooperative overlap": a way of showing enthusiastic listenership and eager participation. That is precisely what she found in her early analysis of conversational style (Tannen2005).If one participant expects cooperative overlapping, but the other expects one person to speak at a time, the latter may perceive an intended cooperative overlap as interruption and stop speaking. In this case, the interruption, and the impression of dominance, resulted from the ambiguity of speaking-along rather than from an attempt to dominate. Asituation of polysemy obtains when those for whom speaking-along is assign of eager participation may in fact interrupt and try to wrest the floor from a current speaker, confident that their conversational partner will do the same and grab it back. In that case, speaking-along "means" both dominance and solidarity. In other words, Tannen's approach doesn't deny the effect and impact of dominance through interruption, but it demonstrates that the effect of dominance may not always result from an intention to dominate, because the same linguistic features can serve either or both status(or dominance) and connection. Differing conversational rituals, growing out of their divergent conversational goals, can result in dominance in family interaction. Ochs and Taylor (1992 ) identify a ritual that typifies dinner-table conversation in many American families: individuals tell what happened to them during the day. The authors found that children's self-reported behavior was the most frequently judged by others. Fathers were the most frequent critics of others' behavior, and rarely had their own behavior criticized or judged. Mothers had their self-reported actions held up for judgment as often as they judged their children's. The result was a family power structure with fathers at the top, children at the bottom, and mothers in the middle. Tannen observes that mothers' self-reports of daily problems is a kind of troubles talk, typically intended to create solidarity, which men often misread as a request to offer advice. Seen this way, the resulting power imbalance might stem in part from the interaction of divergent gendered conversational rituals. Tannen (1996b)further demonstrates the inextricability of difference and dominance in her analysis of workplace communication, where she demonstrates that language strategies used by those in positions of authority are not simply ways of exercising power but are ways of balancing the simultaneous but potentially conflicting needs for status and connection _ ways she identifies, following Goff man (1977),as "sex-class" linked, that is, associated with the class of women and the class of men, where "class" derives from Bertrand Russell's notion of logical types. To illustrate, she compares two instances of small talk between status unequal. In one interaction, two men who are discussing a computer glitch negotiate status and connection through challenges; bonding against women; and alternating displays of helping, expertise, and independence (needing no help). The women's conversation occurred while the highest-status woman was telling a story to two lower ranking colleagues.
Conclusion :
Research on language and gender has increasingly become research on gender and discourse. A movement toward the study of language within specific situated activities reflects the Importance of culturally defined meanings both of linguistic strategies and of gender. It knowledge the agency of individuals In creating gendered identities, including the options of resisting and transgressing sociocultural norms for linguistic behavior. But it also knowledge the sociocultural constraints within which individuals make their linguistic choices, and the impact of those constraints . Whether they are adhered to or departed from. In sense, the field of gender and discourse has thus come full returning to its root in Madura.
NOTES
1 Feminist writers currently recognize
three waves of feminism: a first wave
defined by the suffragist movement; a
second wave for women's
REFERENCES
empowerment from the 19605 through
the 19805; and a third wave focused on
diversity and linked with
postmodernism beginning in the 19905.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar